Thursday morning started with a decent gap higher following a tremendous bout of selling this week. What made today’s gap particularly interesting was that SPY was opening back above its 200-day SMA.
What is wild is how similar this price action is to November 4th and 5th.
Back on November 4th, SPY gapped back above its 100-day SMA, which was a bullish sign. At the time, I said it needed to hold that moving average or things could get nasty. Well, nasty they got.
Fast forward to Thursday morning. The gap above the 200-day SMA was a good start to a potential bullish relief bounce, but it had to do one thing: hold the 200-day SMA.
Just like November 5th, SPY took out that moving average after trapping the bulls and cascaded lower throughout the day. It ultimately closed at the lows, leaving behind a mega death candle.
SPY Daily Chart
The 1998 Analog Strikes Again
I have to mention that the 1998 analog is playing out perfectly right now. There is one issue with it, though: Where exactly should the red box end?
Currently, I have it ending a bit below the prior all-time highs, because that is where price retested in 1998. That level also happens to represent a 7% pullback from the first rate hike day, a historical study I have been discussing frequently since September. However, there are two other ways to look at it.
First, in 1998, price retraced approximately 94% of the preceding bull run (green box). Applying that same measurement to today’s market would take SPY all the way down to $638. That is a much more bearish scenario than simply retesting the prior all-time highs.
The other way to look at it is through time. The steepest part of the 1998 decline took place over just four trading sessions below the 200-day SMA. Those four days took price down approximately 13%. If that same move played out today, we would be looking at SPY around $638 by early next week.
Without some kind of black swan event, I don’t think that happens now. But it did happen in 2025, 2020, 2015, and 2010. Hmm, come to think of it, it seems to happen every five years. Obviously, it won't happen two years in a row, right? Right?!
SPY Daily Chart - 1998 Analog
Anyway, if we focus on the number of days rather than the percentage decline, the analog suggests SPY could sell off sharply for another day or two before putting in some form of reversal. We are currently 44 days off the highs. In 1998, it took 42 days from the highs before a low formed.
That lends credibility to the idea that if we sell off hard for another few days into the $700 area, or perhaps a bit below it, we could be approaching a short-term low. That would potentially offer a very attractive risk/reward opportunity back toward the 200-day SMA, at the very least.
Two Ways to Approach This Market
So, with the possibility of SPY dropping to $700, which has been my base case based on the historical drawdowns following new rate-hiking regimes, and the possibility of a gap fill all the way down to $660, how should traders and investors manage risk? More importantly, what should we actually be looking for when a bottom starts to form?
With proper risk management, I see two primary options:
Buy weakness at key support levels. Identify important price levels, enter against them, and have a predefined stop or hedge level in place in case support fails.
Wait for bullish “confirmation”. Let the market show its hand. Wait for bullish signals to appear and get long once there is more evidence that a bottom is forming.
Of course, someone could also dollar-cost average into companies they like for the long term, but that isn’t what we are discussing here.
You are either buying on weakness or buying on strength. Both approaches have their downsides and upsides.
Buying weakness means you may take a few losses or paper cuts along the way before the one trade that actually works out pays for the others. Buying strength means you will likely miss the exact bottom and pay a higher price for confirmation.
That is trading. You don’t have to nail the exact low. You need to manage risk well enough to participate when the opportunity finally presents itself.
QQQ Daily Chart
What Do Market Bottoms Usually Look Like?
I am always studying charts, so tonight I went back and looked at bottoms during bull markets on QQQ, going all the way back to 2009. I wanted to see what those bottoms looked like technically and whether they coincided with some kind of fundamental catalyst.
Looking at the major corrections and bottoms during the current bull market, most had at least two common ingredients: high volume and a bullish gap. Many also had a secondary news event that helped confirm the low.
Several of those news events involved a pivot from the Federal Reserve or some other major development that affected monetary policy.
The old saying, “Don’t fight the Fed,” is the real deal, especially when looking at more recent market history.
Here are a few examples:
2018: The Fed pivots to patience
The market bottomed following a brutal selloff and a wave of short covering. The bottom was then confirmed with a bullish gap and go on January 4th, 2019, when Jerome Powell pivoted toward a more patient approach to monetary policy.
QQQ 2018
2020: QE Infinity
Once again, we saw massive short covering. The bottom was confirmed with a bullish gap and go on April 6th as the Fed’s unprecedented monetary stimulus, often referred to as QE Infinity, helped stabilize the market.
QQQ 2020
2025: The tariff pause
The market bottomed after Trump announced a 90-day pause on tariffs. The bottom was subsequently confirmed on April 22nd with a bullish gap and go, following news that US-China tariffs were unsustainable and that Fed Chair Powell would not be fired.
QQQ 2025
2026: The first crash
Stocks found a bottom following positive developments with Iran. The confirmation came on April 8th with a breakaway gap above the major moving averages following the US-Iran ceasefire.
QQQ 2026
The common thread is worth paying attention to. We didn’t simply get a random green candle and declare the bottom in. We saw big volume, bullish gaps, and often some kind of fundamental catalyst that changed the market’s outlook.
That is what I want to see again.
I will be watching closely for one of two things. The first is a gap down capitulation move that produces a large reversal candle with a clear level around which I can manage risk. The second is a bullish gap and go that holds, followed by another gap higher to help confirm the move.
If we gap down slightly tomorrow, that won’t do it for me. I want a large gap, lots of fear, heavy volume, and long lower wicks. I want to see sellers exhaust themselves and buyers step in aggressively.
The key to navigating any market like this is solid risk management. Buying dips blindly is a good way to dig yourself into a hole that can take years to climb out of. You don’t need to catch the exact bottom, but you do need to know where you’re wrong, how much you’re willing to risk, and have a plan going into each day.










Thank you!
You always do stellar analysis! Thanks!